A response to the provocative question posed by Maha Bali, Taskeen Adam, Catherine Cronin, Christian Friedrich, Sukaina Walji, Christina Hendricks’s (+ Martin Weller and Jamison Miller):
How do we use openness to exclude, overpower and/or oppress marginalized individuals, communities, knowledge systems?
Initial reaction: This question assumes that “we” are the ones in the privileged position. Asking it from a place of power, a place of comfort and confidence. The question also assumes that there is somewhere a united “we” – could this be the OER18 community?
How do we use openness to exclude, overpower and/or oppress the other, whoever that might be?
The other doesn’t have to be “the marginalized.” Their opinions and habits might actually matter. For politicians it can be another group with power. For designers it can be the “end user.” For educators the other can be students.
The other might be anyone or anything we want to silence, exercise our power on, take advantage of, make profit from.
Refined reaction: But…something isn’t right..
Could it be because I have created the “other” with the way I asked the question?
Could it be because there is something missing in this question… a sense of connection… connection with real life and experiences, people’s stories.
Could it be because exclusion, overpowering and oppression are different things? They can be very different things and can come in many forms.
What does all of this mean for me?
Has there been a time where openness excluded, overpowered, or oppressed me? How so? How did I feel about it? What did I do about it? What could I have done about it?
Ok, this feels quite personal and the search for experience is emotional.
Has there been a time where openness excluded, overpowered, or oppressed YOU? How so? How did you feel about it? What did you do about it? What could you have done about it?
I’m asking something personal. Something that matters to you. Something that made you feel bitter. Or something that you aren’t even aware of yet. I don’t know what this might be, I don’t want to make assumptions. Only you could tell me.
Verdict (for now):
- Avoid assumptions based on limited experience.
- Initiate a dialogue, not a serial monologue.
- Open yourself to feelings and experiences.
What do you think?